Monday, October 12, 2009
Surprised?
As the health care debate continues to rage, civil discourse appears to still be lacking. This time, it is the Democrats who are guilty. Just a couple of weeks after Representative Joe Wilson shouted the words, "You lie!" during President Obama's address to Congress, Representative Alan Grayson describes the Republican health care plan as one asking Americans to simply not get sick, and if you do, then die quickly. Grayson, of course, does not see the comparison.
What Grayson fails to recognize is that not only is he on par with Wilson in terms of lack of civility, but he may be far more off base. Yes, Republicans may have exaggerated the provision in H.R. 3200 regarding end of life counseling, which has been coined as death panels. But at the very least this stemmed from a legitimate concern that both the Republican party and many Americans shared. Alan Grayson, however, has nothing to exaggerate here. His comments are baseless, offensive, and worst of all, counterproductive. Coincidentally, whereas Joe Wilson was ordered to apologize both before the House and to President Obama directly, Grayson has been ordered to make no such apology for his antics, or withdraw his statement.
Democrats would be wise to distance themselves from Representative Grayson and turn their attention back to the work that needs to be done to pass health care reform.
More information can be found in this article by Anthony Del Pellegrino.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
To answer your question--not at all. Both parties routinely engage in these divisive tactics and inaccurate claims. Rep. Wilson's outburst was inappropriate, ill-timed, and above all disrespectful. Rep. Grayson's comments are what Democrats themselves call "fear tactics", nonetheless being an argument devoid of any sound reasoning. It does seem as if civil discourse has gradually disappeared from the political arena. I wonder how much of the strife is a result of the political polarization caused by the previous and current administration's philosophies (neo-conservative and progressive) which are often unfavorable to promoting more moderate, compromising attitudes.
ReplyDelete